To be honest, I like them both ways, but I probably prefer them shaken over ice. Shake it like you mean it! Pineapple wedge and a cherry for garnish. 1 oz. 1/2 cup crushed ice. (½ cup/120ml) cream of coconut (see recipe below, or use ½ cup of the thick cream scooped from the top of a can of full-fat coconut milk ... 4 oz. Choose a good rum. Make sure to use the best pineapple juice. (120ml) unsweetened pineapple juice. Directions: Mix rum, cream of coconut, heavy cream … Pina Coladas can be served blended, which is how you most often see them, or shaken and served over ice. 6 oz. Know the difference between cream of coconut or coconut cream. 1 cup (about 140gms) fresh or frozen pineapple chunks. We recommend using fresh pineapple juice. A Pina Colada cocktail is a sweet run drink made with cream of coconut and pineapple juice. pineapple juice . heavy cream.